This section is from the book "Phantasms Of The Living", by Edmund Gurney, Frederic W. H. Myers, Frank Podmore. Also available from Amazon: Phantasms of the Living.
§ 1. The term thought-transference has been adopted in preference to thought-reading, the latter term (1) having become identified with exhibitions of muscle-reading, and (2) suggesting a power of reading a person's thoughts against his will .... . . . . . . . 8-9
§ 2. The phenomena of thought-transference first attracted the attention of competent witnesses in connection with "mesmerism," and were regarded as one of the peculiarities of the mesmeric rapport; which was most prejudicial to their chance of scientific acceptance ....... 9-10
§ 3. Hints of thought-transference between persons in a normal state were obtained by Professor Barrett in 1876; and just at that time the attention of others had been attracted to certain phenomena of the "willing-game," which were not easily explicable (as almost all the so-called "willing" and "thought-reading" exhibitions are) by unconscious muscular guidance. But the issue could never be definitely decided by cases where the two persons concerned were in any sort of contact ......... 10-13
§ 4. And even where contact is excluded, other possibilities of unconscious guidance must be taken into account; as also must the possibility of conscious collusion. Anyone who is unable to obtain conviction as to the bona fides of experiments by himself acting as agent or percipient (and so being himself one of the persons who would have to take part in the trick, if trick it were), may fairly demand that the responsibility for the results shall be spread over a considerable group of persons - a group so large that he shall find it impossible to extend to all of them the hypothesis of deceit (or of such imbecility as would take the place of deceit) which he might apply to a smaller number . 14-16
§ 5. Experiments with the Creery family; earlier trials . . . 16-18
More conclusive experiments, in which knowledge of what was to be transferred (usually the idea of a particular card, name, or number) was confined to the members of the investigating committee who acted as agents; with a table of results, and an estimate of probabilities . . . . . .18-21
In many cases reckoned as failures there was a degree of approximate success which was very significant ........ 21-22
The form of the impression in the percipient's mind seems to have been sometimes visual and sometimes auditory ...... 22
§ 6. Reasons why these experiments were not accessible to a larger number of observers; the chief reason being the gradual decline of the percipient faculty ............ 22-24
§ 7. In a course of experiments of the same sort conducted by M. Charles Richet, in France, the would-be percipients were apparently not persons of any special susceptibility; but a sufficient number of trials were made for the excess of the total of successes over the total most probable if chance alone acted to be decidedly striking ........ 24-26
The pursuit of this line of inquiry on a large scale in England has produced results which involve a practical certainty that some cause other than chance has acted ........... 26 - 27
§ 8. Experiments in the reproduction of diagrams and rough drawings. In a long series conducted by Mr. Malcolm Guthrie, two percipients and a considerable number of agents were employed ...... 27-30
Specimens of the results ........ 30-40
§ 9. Professor Oliver J. Lodge's experiments with Mr. Guthrie's "subjects," and his remarks thereon ......... 41-43
§ 10. Experiments in the transference of elementary sensations - tastes, smells, and pains .......... 43-48
§ 11. A different department of experiment is that where the transference does not take effect in the percipient's consciousness, but is exhibited in his motor system, either automatically or semi-automatically. Experiments in the inhibition of utterance ......... 48-50
§ 12. The most conclusive cases of transference of ideas which, nevertheless, do not affect the percipient's consciousness are those where the idea is reproduced by the percipient in writing, without his being aware of what he has written. Details of a long series of trials carried out by the Rev. P. H. and Mrs. Newnham .......... 50-56
The intelligence which acted on the percipient's side in these experiments was in a sense an unconscious intelligence - a term which needs careful definition 56-57
§ 13. M. Richet has introduced an ingenious method for utilising what he calls "mediumship" - i.e., the liability to exhibit intelligent movements in which consciousness and will take no part - for purposes of telepathic experiment. By this method it has been clearly shown that a word on which the agent concentrates his attention may be unconsciously reproduced by the percipient ........... 57-61
And even that a word which has only an unconscious place in the agent's mind may be similarly transferred ....... 61-64
These phenomena seem to involve a certain impulsive quality in the transference ............ 64-65
§ 14. Apart from serious and systematic investigation, interesting results are sometimes obtained in a more casual way, of which some specimens are given. It is much to be wished that more persons would make experiments, under conditions which preclude the possibility of unconscious guidance. At present we are greatly in the dark as to the proportion of people in whom the specific faculty exists ......... 65-69
 
Continue to: