§ 2. Passing now to examples where the supposed agent was awake, but in a perfectly ordinary and unexcited state, we must still, of course, reject cases where any normal cause for the dream can be plausibly assigned. Thus Mr. F. J. Jones, of Heath Bank, Mossley Road, Ashton-under-Lyne, tells us how his little daughter astonished him by starting up from her sleep, saying, "Something has gone wrong with the 'Gogo's' boilers." The "Gogo" belonged to a firm with which Mr. Jones was connected, and it was afterwards discovered that the boilers had at that very time suffered an accident in the Bay of Biscay. The coincidence remains, therefore, an odd one; but we should certainly be inclined to refer the child's dream to some scrap of grown-up conversation that had been forgotten. Mr. E. W. P., of Barton End Grange, Nailsworth, describes how in a half-wakeful state he had been imagining himself to be reading "The Book of Days," till it seemed to become too dark to see - when all at once his wife said in her sleep, " You should not read in bed, it is so bad for the eyes." On inquiry, we find that Mrs. P. is not in the habit of talking in her sleep; but we find also that Mr. P. has often read in bed, and that his wife has often remonstrated with him about it.

The following cases seem free from such objections.

Mrs. Crellin, of 62, Hilldrop Crescent, N., says: -

"August, 1884.

(96) "I mentioned to you my husband's awaking from sleep and repeating the line from Tennyson which I had been trying to remember [i.e., No. 95, omitted]. That seemed to me a brain-wave, and it was immediate in its action; but what of a deferred brain-wave? Thus, three weeks ago, I was unable to sleep during the early hours of the night. I thought, amongst other things, of a rather comic piece of poetry which my husband used to repeat years ago. I stuck at one line and could not recall it. However, I fell asleep, and three or four hours after awoke, to find it was time to rise. My husband, after a good night's rest - undisturbed by poetry or prose - awoke also; he stretched out his hand towards me, and repeated the line I had failed to remember in the night, and which did not occupy my thoughts when I awoke in the morning. This seemed a strange delay in giving the response."1

Mr. Crellin says: -

" 62, Hilldrop Crescent, N.

"August 20th, 1884.

" My wife has told you of an incident which I am able to confirm. I awoke one morning recently, and immediately said to her, 'And his skin, like a lady's loose gown, hung about him' - this being a line of some humorous verses learnt by me when a youth, and which I have occasionally recited for the amusement of my friends, but which I had not repeated or thought of for a long period. My wife at once said that whilst lying awake during the night (I being asleep) she had been trying to recall this very line. I know of nothing that can have brought the line to my mind and lips at the moment.

1 We need not regard it as specially strange. See p. 144.

"Philip Crellin".

The force of cases where a dream exactly reproduces the thoughts of a person in the dreamer's vicinity is so much increased by their multiplication in the experience of the same two persons, that the following additional instance, from the narrators of case 90, needs no apology, Mrs. Fielding writes: -

"Yarlington Rectory, Bath, 19th May, 1886.

(700) "I sleep badly, and on Monday night it was 2 o'clock when I slept. I had, for half an hour before going off, fixed my mind upon every turn and corner of my girlhood's home (where I have not been for above 20 years) in Scotland. My father, a squire, had a neighbour squire, called Harvey Brown. In my whiling away the night, I dwelt upon him, and his house and family, particularly. My husband knew him only by name, but, of course, knew my home, and loves it as much as I do. He and I awoke at 6. Before a word of any kind was said, he said to me, ' I have had such a strange dream about Harvey Brown, and been at the old home, wandering about it.' What made it seem stranger is that Harvey Brown is a man we never spoke of in our lives, or for 20 years have ever thought of, till Monday night in idleness I went over old meetings with him; and I was wide awake and my husband asleep; he had slept heavily all the night after a 12-mile walk; so there was no possibility of my leading his mind near Scotland, in any conversation even, before he slept.

"Jean Eleanora Fielding.

"J. M. Fielding".

[To this may be added, as belonging to this section, another case from the Additional Chapter, where the transferred impression emerged in a dream, not remembered by the dreamer, but known to have occurred through "his talking in his sleep. - Ed.] Mrs. Lethbridge, of Tregeare, Launceston, Cornwall, writes: -

"Bella Vista, Corsier, Vevey, Switzerland.

"April 10th, 1886.