This section is from the book "Sleep Psychologically Considered With Reference To Sensation And Memory", by Blanchard Fosgate. Also available from Amazon: Sleep Psychologically Considered with Reference to Sensation and Memory.
Eliza Bullard - our patient - aged fifteen years, by birth a French Canadian, of a bilio-nervous temperament, was suddenly seized with convulsions, which continued at intervals for about six weeks. The paroxysms occurred many times a day, each lasting from a few minutes to two or three hours. The muscular contractions were occasionally so violent, that the back of the head and soles of the feet were brought nearly in juxtaposition.
For about two weeks of this period, when her voluntary muscular system was in the most rigid condition, she would sing one or two hymns so loud and clear, that they could be distinctly heard at ten or twelve rods from her dwelling. After singing, she usually commenced praying in an under tone. The words could be heard by attentive listening. Religious thoughts and exercises occupied her mind during the paroxysm. Several times we tried to resist the lower jaw in its movements, when articulating the words of the hymn, but it felt like grasping a piece of machinery, driven by a resistless motive power: the motion could not be impeded. After the paroxysm had subsided, she remembered nothing that had passed, and was much affected when informed of her musical performance. She could always be relieved of the spasm in about three fourths of an hour, by placing far back on her tongue two drops of Croton Oil. This case we relate, merely as an additional illustration of mental activity, independent of external sensation and without memory.
The senses may be intact, the motor apparatus subject to the will, and yet the mind perceive not the movements of the body, although the inception of the act arose in the brain. When one of a series of movements is started, the whole catenation may be completed by the mere influence of reflex action, without a mental perception. "In 1834, Maria Pau was admitted into the hospital at Bordeaux", her left hand and arm covered with deep and bleeding gashes, its tendons projecting, and the bones broken. She had, in her sleep, gone into a loft to cut wood with a hedging bill; thinking she was cutting the wood, she had hacked her forearm and hand until she fainted away, and fell bathed in her blood. She had felt no pain, but merely had a sensation as if the parts were pricked with pins." The case of the individual who leaped from the hotel-window, previously related, is of the same character. In the leap his ankle joint was severely sprained, but it made no impression upon his mind. A series of actions somewhat resembling these, may be observed in certain animals of the lower orders. Neither brain nor nerve can be found in the polype, but it moves by irritability, and exists without sensation or consciousness.
Now if these views are philosophic, a part of the external senses may be impressible, and yet convey no impression to the mind, but still guide the locomotive operations. Under such circumstances, the mind is in the same condition, so far as the influence of nerves is concerned, as though they were entirely inactive, and therefore does not disturb the theory, that memory of what occurs during sleep depends upon perception of external relation through the sensitive organs. For if the locomotive power resides in the spinal cord, and if locomotion occurs during sleep, and if the mind does not perceive through the nerves of sense the movements of the body, there justly can be no perception, although there may be sensation, and in this case, we apprehend, there is no memory of occurrences connected with our existence: and as before stated, 'there are many cases of somnambulism in which the mind seems not to participate.' The somnambulist receives the first impulse to action from the will; after which, locomotion is continued through the force of reflex and associate or consensual action.
It would further appear that memory is dependent upon the organs of external sensation, from the fact that it is not only observed in ordinary sleep, the mesmeric state, somnambulism, catalepsy, in some instances of insanity, but in trance also. When treating of this last condition, two cases were related which are here applicable. The case of Mrs. Godfrey, without sensation, and no remembrance of the circumstances ; and the case of the young woman, taken from the "Psychological Magazine," who felt her attendants pull on the dead clothes, and heard them sing the funeral hymn, and on recovery had a perfect remembrance of all that occurred during that dreadful period.
It may be remarked, that the reason why in the former instance there was no memory, was because the patient was unconscious. Our view is, that the mind is never asleep - never in abeyance - never unconscious. When the external channels of information are closed, it receives no knowledge from without, and is then only conscious of influences from within. The affections or feelings are now its stimulus of action, and mental operations having their excitement in the activity of these organs, which, with Combe, we believe not to possess memory, the mental operations are not retained. Even in the apoplectic coma, which may be so profound that the patients cannot by any means be aroused from their lethargy, it is no uncommon occurrence to hear them muttering about circumstances connected with their business-affairs, and on recovery, retain no remembrance of having even dreamed during the paroxysm; but they were conscious of internal influences, otherwise there would have been no manifestation of thought.
Memory, therefore, we conceive to be connected with the activity of the organs of perception, and when they are stimulated by external impressions, this faculty is fully developed. When the same organs are excited, either by the influence of the propensities or intellectual operations, as in sound sleep, and in some cases of trance, the memorial power is in abeyance; but when they are stimulated by that nervous mode of action inducing phantasm, their relation is precisely. the same as if really impressed by physical objects.
We are aware that some circumstances seem to present objections to these views. But when we contemplate the proportional decline of memory and sensation, as age advances, and also take into consideration the fact that judgment and volition are unimpaired by the same cause, and that we can at will recall the memory of long past events as perfectly and with as much facility, as at any former period; and when we perceive the same phenomena exhibited in the withholding the transmission of surrounding influences in sleep with its analogous states ; we can scarcely come to any other conclusion, than that external sensation and memory are most intimately connected, and that the mind is dependent in proportion to the integrity of the organs of objective communication, for its remembrance of what occurs during sleep.
 
Continue to: