This section is from the book "Sleep Psychologically Considered With Reference To Sensation And Memory", by Blanchard Fosgate. Also available from Amazon: Sleep Psychologically Considered with Reference to Sensation and Memory.
To establish with greater certainty the doctrines, that the mind is absolutely sleepless; and that we are dependent on external sensation for a remembrance of what passes in the mind in somnolency; it becomes necessary to take a cursory survey of our preceding observations. In this, however, we shall not recapitulate in detail the facts on which those doctrines are founded, but only consider their general bearing, and by the introduction of other circumstances corroborative, endeavor to confirm our propositions.
Sleep is a phenomenon of that part of our existence by which we are connected with the external world, and during sleep the mental operations proceed, though modified by its influence. During this state, the mind is restricted in its operations to the stimulus afforded by the activity of the innate powers of the cerebral organization, and as one consequence of this activity, the memory of past events is brought to view. We arrive at this conclusion from those states of mind in which we perceive that by-gone circumstances are recalled and associated in the mental process. And although, in these operations, the mind is brought to a remembrance of what has passed, the memory is not impressed with the thoughts which occupy it while external sensations do not contribute their stimuli to its operations. To this conclusion we come, from those states of being in which we know that the mind was active while the senses were dormant, and there was no remembrance on awaking of what then transpired. From the facts that the mind is active without the stimulus of external sensation, but that without this stimulus there is no memory, and that the perception can be as readily stimulated by the internal as external sensations, we conclude that it is exclusively through the activity of the organs of perception that the memorial faculty is manifested, and that these organs must be approached through the special senses to develope this mental power.
If ceaseless activity of the mental organ exists not only during sleep, but in every condition short of dissolution, why should not one train of thought be remembered equally well with another? The reason is, that perfect sleep disconnects the external world and mind, and any mental operation not based in concurrent outward relation, cannot be recollected.
Memory, we repeat, is a mental element manifested through the activity of the organs of perception. It is requisite, however, that these organs receive their stimulus from certain sources, otherwise the memorial faculty will not be impressed. When they receive their stimulus from external objects, this faculty is developed. When they receive their stimulus from the propensities or sentiments, the resulting mental operations are not remembered. From this circumstance, we apprehend, phrenology has concluded that the animal organs are not possessed of memory; but whether they are or not, they do not (as will afterwards appear) stamp the result of their stimulus indelibly upon the mind.
Universal experience teaches that what we see or hear, we remember better than what we imagine or read about, because memory is much clearer and more durable when its objects are perceived through the external senses, than when it is merely a deduction of the mind, or in other words, when it is only an intellectual impression.
The perceptive faculty has three sources of stimulus; viz. through the media of internal and external sensations, and the powers of reflection. The thoughts which follow the impressions of the first, when unconnected with the second, are not remembered; and those flowing from the last, under similar circumstances, are imperfectly retained; but the perception of impressions received through the organs of external sense, developes the memorial faculty in its fullest power.
Through perverted or imperfect sensations, perception is so modified, that dreaming and insanity singularly harmonize. The perceptions being in consonance with the state of the impressions transmitted, the perception of actual existences is imperfect, and memory fails to recall and associate the past with the present in accordance with reality: - hence some of the incongruous results of the mental operation during these states.
In old age the organs of sense lose their nice property of receiving impressions perfectly ; consequently the perceptions are indistinct and the memory of recent occurrences is defective, but the remembrance of circumstances which occurred in times long past, when the senses were intact, is comparatively fresh in the mind. The mental operations that depended upon the internal impressions of those times are forgotten, and only those in which the external senses largely contributed, are retained. If memory, as advocated by Dr. Combe, be a mode of activity of the knowing or perceptive organs, and if this activity can be stimulated by the will, then we may possibly account for this peculiar feature of advanced age. Early impressions having been made upon organs in good condition to receive and transmit them accurately to the perceptive faculties, a corresponding effect was there produced. Now volition is little impaired by age, and through this power the mind can at will recall mental perceptions; but the perception of impressions made through impaired organs of communication, is so feeble from the imperfection of the instruments employed, that owing to this feeble perception there is but little for the will to act upon, and consequently, early perceptions are readily recalled, while those of recent occurrence are indistinctly remembered..
 
Continue to: